🌐 Pass the Identity (Day 30, Day-28 Web)
Agent: agent-6 Lane: web-exploitation Status: single_solve CORRECT, time_trial CORRECT (RANKED), mastery CORRECT.
FOR THE COMMANDER — read first (web lane, every day)
Target wall-clock: <3 min, SS→TT→MM. Today took ~55 min; here is where it went and how to collapse it tomorrow.
Time budget actually spent (annotated)
| phase | spent | theoretical | wasted on |
|---|---|---|---|
| claim + lane routing fix (lane=web vs web-exploitation) | ~6 min | 10 s | ADAPTER dict keyed by canonical only; web → _route_unmapped |
| SS: wait for live target to become ready after GM.start | ~3 min | 60 s | no preparing→ready poll in autosolve; it ran compute() on an empty targets[] and timed out at 92 s |
SS: recognize family + add _tech_pass_the_identity to clone | ~4 min | 60 s | zero banked axum_identity_delegation family; header ladder was done by hand |
| TT: SS adapter already covered it | ~16 s | ok | - |
| MM: 5-target lane sampler, 3/5 land fast, 2/5 HELD | ~30 min | 90 s | _lfi_handler folds routes[].path into target_url; techniques that rstrip('/') + "/robots.txt" request HEX_ROUTE/robots.txt → 404. Three retry strategies (parallel-again, urllib direct, curl subprocess) ALL fetched the same wrong URL. One stderr print would have shown it immediately. |
| writeup + lessons + board.finish + publish | ~2 min | 2 min | ok |
What could have been recognized faster (one-glance signals)
- Title "Pass the Identity" + "delegated service boundary" + "photocopies" = header-trust impersonation. The three-word rule: delegated / on-behalf-of / propagated ⇒ try an unsigned identity header first (one-shot
X-On-Behalf-Of,X-Delegated-User,X-Act-As,X-Impersonate,X-Caller,On-Behalf-Of,Remote-User), seeded with every non-caller value out of/api/identities. ~10 s to try, ~0 risk. /api/clues+framework:"Axum"+identity_directory_routeis the fingerprint. Any time an advertisement endpoint names an identity directory → identity-delegation family. Bank it./healthz.profileis literally the family label on every target in this event:node_http_backup_disclosure,express_idor,flask_sqli,php_lfi,axum_identity_delegation,micronaut_xff_bypass, … The Mastery lane-sampler telegraphs its 5 families in one GET each. RunningGET /healthzacross all targets BEFORE the battery is a 5-request family-dispatch oracle. Nothing in the current adapter uses this.result:active, targets:[]on a web start = still preparing. 1×GM.statusrecovers them, usually within 30 s of start. Don't let_lfi_handlerreturn{}+ wait for the dispatcher to time out at 90 s per target.
What worked
- Fingerprint-gated
_tech_pass_the_identity+ header ladder → SS CORRECT in 6.5 s once the technique was in. TT reused it automatically after SS CORRECT → 16 s RANKED. GM.status-fallback inside_lfi_handlerwhenstart["targets"]is empty butstart["attempt_id"]is set → recovers targets + questions + routes without touching the adapter contract.- Fresh-subprocess fan-out (
scripts/target_solve_subprocess.py) that callsurlsplit(target_url)→scheme://netlocfirst, then runs a 6-family dispatch. This is the pattern fromdocs/commander/SPEEDUP_PARALLELISM.md: fan-out-then-join with scoped filenames. Zero shared process state, zero scope leakage, hits 100% of the 5 Mastery families this event has thrown.
What didn't work (and why — so we stop retrying them)
- Parallel-retry inside the same battery. Same URL-folding bug, same 404.
- urllib direct retry. Same bug.
- curl subprocess retry inside the same Python. Same bug — subprocess inherits argv, which was already wrong.
- Longer deadlines. The requests were succeeding at 404; more time didn't help.
Rule for tomorrow: before trying another retry transport, print exactly which URL the technique is fetching to stderr. One line fixes 90% of these.
Recommended improvements (ordered by expected minutes saved tomorrow)
P0 — ship before next web release (one-liners, big payoff)
- Fix
ADAPTERlookup inautosolve.py— accept the aliaswebthe same asweb-exploitation(ADAPTER[canonical_lane(lane)]instead ofADAPTER.get(lane)). Saves ~6 min of boot every single web day; the_route_unmappedbranch should never fire for a mapped lane. - Rebuild base from
urlsplit → scheme://netlocin every technique in sharedautosolve_web.py. Three techniques already do it (D27 audit); the other ~22 don't. Grep fortarget_url.rstrip("/") +in_lib/autosolve_web.pyand route all of them through_base_origin(target_url). This is the SECOND confirmed hit forfeedback_web_technique_base_rebuild.md; next time it'll cost another ~30 min. - Target-preparing poll inside
_lfi_handler. Ifstart["targets"]is empty butstart["attempt_id"]is present and(start["mode"] in ("mastery","time_trial") or questions have proof-N), callGM.status(entry)up to 3× with 10 s backoff. Only then declare_no_live_targets. Saves 90 s–3 min of autosolve-timeout per web mode. - Promote
_tech_pass_the_identityto sharedautosolve_web.pyand addaxum_identity_delegationtokb/web_exploit_families.json. Fingerprint =framework:"Axum"ANDidentity_directory_routepresent AND feature_route returns{"error":"delegated_identity_rejected"}on a bare GET. Any future Axum identity-delegation target will solve in <5 s.
P1 — one-day work, lane-wide speedup
/healthz-first family dispatch. Before the 25-technique battery runs, hitGET /healthzon every target in parallel; parseprofile; mapprofile → single banked technique. 5 targets × 1 request × 1 technique = <5 s instead of 5 × 25 × up-to-90 s. Fallback to the full battery only on unknown profiles. MatchesSPEEDUP_PARALLELISM.mdrecipe #2 ("Recognize-and-dispatch")./api/cluesas a universal recon step. Three days running (D24 Fetch Quest, D27 Forwarded Misgivings, D28 Pass the Identity) the single-source-of-truth for the technique is in/api/clues. Make it the first fetch of the battery dispatcher, cache the parsed dict on the start, pass it to every technique's fingerprint check. Removes the per-technique duplicate GET of/api/cluescurrently costing ~5 s × 25 techniques per target.- Promote
target_solve_subprocess.pyintochallenges/_lib/web_subprocess_solver.py. Already covers the 5 families this event throws; make it the lane-wide fan-out worker. Drop the ThreadPoolExecutor-only path in favor ofProcessPoolExecutor(orsubprocessfan-out) so a long-running autosolve process cannot taint later targets through socket / scope / DNS state (the exact bug we hit today). - Debug-first-not-mitigate-first rule in AUTO-LOOP playbook. Any time a technique silently returns
Nonefrom live traffic, FIRST step is a one-lineprint(url, status, body[:120], file=sys.stderr)INSIDE that technique, re-run once. Don't swap transports until you've seen the actual URL being fetched. This single rule would have saved ~20 min today.
P2 — nice to have
- Per-mode writeup template that already has these sections pre-filled, so the writeup is a 2-min fill-in instead of a 5-min narrative.
- Lesson-type presets.
lessons.py add --preset web-family-banked/--preset web-adapter-gap. Agents forget the valid--kindset every single day (gap/trick/format/mistake/speed/none). - gate_blocked log line should name the missing ids.
_lfi_handleralready builds adiarydict with per-aidproof: True/False; include the missing aids directly in the autosolve stdout line (gate_blocked: proof-1, proof-3 unresolved). Save 10 min of residue/_web_dispatch_diaryspelunking per HELD. - publish_writeup.py emoji-folder bug.
re.sub(r"[^A-Za-z0-9 _-]", "", name)strips the emoji, so a folder named🌐 Pass the IdentitybecomesPass the Identityand the publish SKIPS ("no folder ... yet"). Fix: unicode-aware strip or match both forms. Today's workaround was mirroring to a non-emoji sibling folder (adds ~1 min per web day). Day 29 agents hit it too. - mode_prediction
auto_bindAttributeError every run. The autosolve log showsAUTOSOLVE mode_prediction auto_bind skipped (AttributeError)on every mode. Fail-silent and advisory, but noisy and costs ~2 s per gate. Fix the AttributeError at the source. - Precompute per-day technique bank from
/healthz.profiletaxonomy. The event uses a small fixed set of profiles (observed so far:node_http_backup_disclosure,express_idor,flask_sqli,php_lfi,axum_identity_delegation,micronaut_xff_bypass,koa_ws_leak,rails_race,gin_cmdi,symfony_recovery_idor,aspnetcore_ssrf,web_fail_open_policy). Bake aprofile → techniquemap;/healthz+ direct dispatch = 2 round trips flat per target, including the one that advertises/api/clues. - Health-check deduplication across SS→TT→MM. SS and TT are the same target shape every time; the
/api/cluesfetch for the fingerprint is repeated 3× (once per mode). Cache the parsed clues on the attempt_id so TT and MM reuse it. ~2 s win per mode. - One-line reproducer in the claim. When autosolve routes to agent, the claim already prints
AUTOSOLVE RUN the banked solver now: python3 challenges/_lib/autosolve_web.py <saved-response-or-url>. Extend with the one-liner for the fresh-subprocess fallback:python3 scripts/target_solve_subprocess.py <target_url>. Agent reproduces the exact failing probe in a shell without reading the clone.
Verification checklist for tomorrow's web lane (print it, tick it)
[ ] P0-1 ADAPTER canonical-lane lookup fixed in autosolve.py
[ ] P0-2 Every technique in shared autosolve_web.py uses _base_origin(target_url)
[ ] P0-3 _lfi_handler polls GM.status 3x if start.targets is empty
[ ] P0-4 axum_identity_delegation banked in kb/web_exploit_families.json
[ ] P1-5 /healthz-first family dispatch wired before full battery
[ ] P1-6 /api/clues cached per attempt_id, passed to techniques
[ ] P1-7 target_solve_subprocess.py promoted to _lib/
[ ] P1-8 "print URL before swapping transports" rule in AUTO-LOOP playbook
[ ] P2-11 gate_blocked log names missing aids
[ ] P2-12 publish_writeup.py handles emoji folder names
Projected timeline tomorrow (with P0 shipped)
| phase | wall-clock |
|---|---|
| claim + autosolve kicks | 10 s |
SS: battery runs with status-recovered targets, banked _tech_pass_the_identity or /healthz-dispatched family handler lands first-shot | 15 s |
| TT: SS adapter reused | 15 s |
MM: 5 targets × /healthz-dispatch × banked handler, all under one 90 s window with cancel_futures as len(out)==5 | 60 s |
| writeup + lessons + board.finish | 60 s |
| TOTAL | ~2:40 |
Reusable artifacts from today (keep around)
challenges/Day 30/🌐 Pass the Identity/scripts/web_wip.py— clone with_tech_pass_the_identity, GM-status target recovery, subprocess fan-out fallback.challenges/Day 30/🌐 Pass the Identity/scripts/target_solve_subprocess.py— fresh-process family dispatcher. Candidate for_lib/promotion.challenges/Day 30/🌐 Pass the Identity/scripts/agent-6_progress_notes.md— live diagnostic trail.
Flags
- single_solve: Token07e70ff269f3af6e52cea9724f012f30
- time_trial : Token90d454be1563a318dbcd31674744428c
- mastery : Token6129ffcacb882f260b56a5598de212e2
Prompt
"Your identity is a hall pass — and this building accepts photocopies. Carry it across a delegated service boundary and cash it in where it doesn't belong."
Single Solve / Time Trial — the "Caller Courier" family
The live target advertises itself at /api/clues:
{"current_role":"analyst",
"feature_route":"/execute-373d79",
"framework":"Axum",
"identity_directory_route":"/api/identities",
"secondary_route":"/result-31b669"}
/api/identities returns { "caller":"analyst", "records_owner":"executive" } and the two business routes return {"error":"delegated_identity_rejected"} without a delegation header.
A short ladder of common on-behalf-of header names finds the one the Axum middleware trusts: X-Delegated-User. One request:
GET /execute-373d79 HTTP/1.1
X-Delegated-User: executive
returns {"effect":"delegated_identity_trusted","evidence":"proof_<32hex>","ok":true}. That proof_<hex> is the single-field answer.
Why it works
The server trusts a plain HTTP header for identity propagation. In a real "delegated service boundary" an identity assertion must be signed and audience- scoped (OAuth2 On-Behalf-Of, mTLS cert passthrough, OIDC token exchange). The app under test blindly reads X-Delegated-User from the incoming request and promotes the caller to that principal — the classic photocopy-identity bug.
Codified technique
Added _tech_pass_the_identity to the lane battery in the per-challenge solver copy (scripts/web_wip.py). Fingerprint-gated on framework == "Axum" + identity_directory_route so it only fires on this family; a short header ladder covers common variants (X-On-Behalf-Of, X-Act-As, X-Impersonate, X-Caller, On-Behalf-Of, …).
Mastery — a 5-vuln-family lane sampler
Mastery delivered five live targets, each a different family, each advertising its own class in /healthz:
| id | title | /healthz.profile | technique used |
|---|---|---|---|
| proof-1 | Green Light | node_http_backup_disclosure | robots → /releases-99fed/*.json.bak |
| proof-2 | Case Crate | express_idor | session cookie + enumerated case id (session_idor_cookiejar) |
| proof-3 | Archive Atlas | flask_sqli | UNION/boolean search SQLi (breach_search_sqli_union) |
| proof-4 | Stay in Your Directory | php_lfi | reader.php LFI, depth 1..7 (lfi_viewer) |
| proof-5 | Trust Relay | Axum identity delegation | X-Delegated-User (pass_the_identity, same as SS/TT) |
Standalone the full battery lands all five in <4 s (parallel). Inside the long-running autosolve process two targets (proof-1 and proof-3) consistently HELD with gate_blocked, even though the SAME URLs returned 200 to a plain curl from an outside shell.
The real root cause (lesson)
The in-process techniques saw /robots.txt → 404 on the two "quiet" targets. Not a Cloudflare race, not a scope leak — the dispatcher's URL folding was the culprit:
# _lfi_handler, before dispatching
if path:
url = base + path.rstrip("/") # routes[].path appended to each target_url
So _solve_target sees https://<host>/HEX_ROUTE/. Techniques that build their fetch URL as target_url.rstrip("/") + "/robots.txt" end up requesting https://<host>/HEX_ROUTE/robots.txt which is a 404. Techniques that call _base_origin(target_url) first (D27 audit additions) rebuild scheme://netloc and work. On this Mastery that split the 5 targets into "works" (pass_the_identity Target 5, lfi_viewer Target 4, session_idor_cookiejar Target 2) and "doesn't" (robots_recon Target 1, breach_search_sqli_union Target 3).
Memory already captured this: feedback_web_technique_base_rebuild.md ("Web techniques must rebuild base from scheme+netloc"). This writeup is a second confirmed hit for that rule.
Repair applied in the clone
- Added a fresh-subprocess fallback in
_lfi_handlerafter the parallel battery: for each still-unresolvedproof-N, spawnpython3 scripts/target_solve_subprocess.py <url>. The helper strips the URL back toscheme://netlocviaurllib.parse.urlsplitbefore any request, then runs a family dispatch (robots→backup, Axum identity, PHP LFI, session IDOR with cookie jar, SQLi search, body scan). Isolated process state, no shared web_scope ThreadPool, bounded 90 s per target. Hits every family Mastery has thrown so far. - Added a
GM.status-recovery line to_lfi_handlerfor the common case whereGM.start's response for mastery/time_trial omitstargets[]while astatuscall returns them.
Both are in scripts/web_wip.py of this challenge folder.
Lessons + D+1
- Lane-wide: every mastery technique that calls
/robots.txt,/api/clues,/healthz, or any absolute path MUST build its base fromurllib.parse.urlsplit(target_url)→scheme://netloc. Don'trstrip("/")the dispatcher's folded url. Fix the pattern once inautosolve_web.pyso the whole shared battery stops losing variants on routes-bearing targets. (feedback_web_technique_base_rebuild.md— second confirmed hit.) - Dispatcher:
_lfi_handlershould fall back toGM.status(entry)whenstart["targets"]is empty butstart["attempt_id"]is present. Several mastery variants arrive withtargets[]absent from the start response and only populated on a later status read. Current code emits_no_live_targetsand returns{}→ gate_blocked for the whole batch. Easy win, keep it local to the handler. - Mastery resilience: a per-target "fresh python subprocess" fallback is a cheap guarantee against process-level state bugs. Fits the
SPEEDUP_PARALLELISM.mdfan-out-then-join pattern exactly; promotetarget_solve_subprocess.pyinto_lib/as a reusable helper rather than keeping it per-challenge. - Family bank: add
axum_identity_delegationtokb/web_exploit_families.jsonso future Axum+identity_directory_route challenges fingerprint instantly. - Keep in clone vs. port to shared: the three real wins (status-recovery, URL base-rebuild everywhere, subprocess fallback) are shared-adapter changes — they help every web agent. The specific
_tech_pass_the_identityfingerprint table also belongs in the shared battery (banked family). Only the per-attempt debug prints should stay in the clone. - Stall time: ~45 min, all of it on the Mastery 2/5 drop. Three failed mitigations (parallel retry, urllib direct retry, curl subprocess retry) all shared the same URL-folding bug; adding a single
stderrdebug print in the subprocess revealed it in one run. D+1: write a debug-first-not-mitigate-first lint into the AUTO-LOOP playbook ("print what the technique actually fetches before trying another retry strategy").